Home 9mm Survival Gear Review: Windham Weaponry R16FTT-9MM Carbine

Survival Gear Review: Windham Weaponry R16FTT-9MM Carbine


Wikipedia has the next to say a few idea referred to as “Confirmation Bias”: “the tendency to seek for, interpret, favor, and recall data in a method that confirms one’s preexisting beliefs or hypotheses. It’s a kind of cognitive bias and a scientific error of inductive reasoning. Folks show this bias after they collect or bear in mind data selectively, or after they interpret it in a biased method. The impact is stronger for desired outcomes, emotionally charged points, and for deeply entrenched beliefs.” Mainly, when one is searching for outcomes or a solution, one tends to view drawn conclusions or carry out analysis in a way that helps a acutely aware or unconscious pre-existing bias. 

By Drew, contributing writer to Survival Cache and SHTFblog

I’ll absolutely admit to initially having been underneath the influences of a full-blown affirmation bias after I first laid my eyes on the Windham Weaponry R16FTT-9MM carbine. My first impression upon seeing Windham Weaponry’s new carbine was most likely much like how may you’re feeling dealing with another Armalite-pattern rifle for the primary time: “Yup, it’s one other AR.” And that’s what I believed this platform could be; yet one more AR. I knew there have been some fascinating options, however total, I believed the 9mm carbine would match into the identical manilla envelope that different ARs do, as a result of I had a preconceived notion of what this little black rifle was all about. And I used to be pleasantly stunned to seek out that really operating this carbine by means of its paces steered me away from searching for information to assist the conclusion I believed I already knew.

Pistol Caliber Magnificence

The Windham Weaponry R16FTT-9MM is a stellar piece of drugs – effectively thought out however not over-designed to the purpose of lunacy. The entire bundle is roughly the identical dimension as your customary M4 carbine, being about 6 ¾ lbs empty with no equipment, and simply shy of 31” lengthy with the inventory collapsed all the way in which in. A 16 inch lengthy medium-weight barrel (with no flash hider or brake) incorporates a 9mm-standard 1:10 rifling twist to stabilize heavier bullets for subsonic masses with out compromising light-bullet accuracy. All the usual AR goodies are included: a free-floating anodized aluminum handguard, a 2” detachable rail part for mounting equipment, and a full-length Picatinny rail that runs repeatedly from the again of the receiver all the way in which to the forwardmost level of the handguard. The A2-style pistol grip and 6-position telescoping CAR-style cuttstock are molded plastic, whereas the aluminum receivers are laborious anodized in a delightful, flawless matte black. The controls are all the place they need to be and function the identical as any AR would. The offered set off is the anticipated Mil-Spec customary setup, and is appropriate with all aftermarket AR-15 hearth management methods. Nothing groundbreaking right here, however no departures from the norm both – an enormous profit for coaching should you already run an AR-15.

Whenever you break the receivers aside, nevertheless, you begin noticing the adjustments that make this Windham Weaponry rifle distinctive. First off, the ejector is mounted into the decrease receiver through two beefy allen screws, and juts upwards from simply behind the journal effectively – a lot totally different (and much less complicated) than the plunger ejector that lives inside customary AR-15 bolts. 

And talking of bolts, popping the R16FTT-9MM’s bolt out of its higher receiver raceway will reveal the massive shock: this gun runs as a straight blowback. That’s proper: no gasoline tubes, no gasoline ports or blocks, no gasoline keys to loosen and leak. No separate rotating bolt for a Multi-piece BCG. The gasses from the spherical going off within the chamber push the bolt backwards and begin the method of the carbine’s semi-automatic biking; the rifle’s springs and physics carry out the remainder of the work. The straight closed-bolt blowback system has been round for over a century now and is well-developed and reliable – and it’s a fantastic, dependable alternative for the operation of this little carbine. Much less shifting elements than HK’s roller-delayed system, no bizarre dissimilar metals friction like a Thompson’s Blish Lock. No wildly unpredicatable accuracy from firing from an open bolt. No fuss, all easy, dependable goodness. It ought to even work effectively as a suppressed rig, too; no worrying in case your gasoline port is appropriately sized or correctly gassed.

Glock Perfection in an AR bundle

The actual crowd-pleasing facet of the Windham Weaponry 9mm carbine is its potential to supply its high-velocity meals from 9mm Glock magazines. That’s proper, proud Glock 17, 18, 19, 26, 34, et.al., homeowners can now run a high-quality AR platform carbine that feeds from magazines which can be already on-hand. For SHTF planning, the utility is apparent – each your lengthy gun and your sidearm can make the most of the very same magazines, easing your logistics pressure as you pile up stacks of double-stack Glock magazines. 

Additionally learn: Magpul PMAG27 Glock Magazine

Making journal acquisition even simpler is the truth that Magpul now affords high-quality, cheap 9mm Glock magazines; as a matter of tact, our topic carbine shipped with a Magpul 17-round journal straight from Windham Weaponry. 

Because the carbine landed in my lap, I’ve been shopping for up a decidedly inconsistent combination of polymer mags; 15-round Glock 19 and 17-round Glock 17 magazines, 33-round Glock “Giggle Sticks”, together with a complement of 15, 17, and 21-round Magpul GL-9 magazines. Each single one in every of them locks into the magwell securely and feeds the little 9mm rounds like greased snot by means of the blowback motion of the Windham Weaponry 9mm Carbine.

The 9mm Glock journal compatibility is a Godsend to these desirous to design a single-caliber centerfire pistol/carbine plan; as a substitute of making an attempt to supply the clunky Colt stick mags, SIG Sauer’s proprietary $60-each MPX magazines, and even pricier MP5 magazines, you’ll be able to stroll into any Cabela’s or fairly well-stocked gun retailer and discover rugged, confirmed magazines on the rack for grime cash; my final buy was a Magpul 17-round journal for $15.99 at Cabelas. I even discovered used Magpul 15-round mags at an area gun store for $10 every. Although I don’t know why somebody would discard something that has “Magpul” moulded into it, I snatched them up with glee they usually perform with aplomb. I purchased the 33-round Glock-made mags for $25 every on sale from Brownell’s.

Icing on the polymer cake: whereas there are a number of producers who make 9mm AR lowers – a number of of whom manufacture with Glock journal functionality – whittling down this increasingly-crowded class additional is the necessity for a 9mm AR decrease that runs on Glock mags, AND ALSO locks the bolt again when the magazine runs dry. The Windham Weaponry 9mm carbine checks all of the above containers with a flawless bolt hold-open function. A rifle that’s theoretically designed for battle or competitors (or perhaps actually intense looking?) ought to completely lock the bolt again when the magazine runs dry. Main kudos to Windham Weaponry for ensuring the rifle operates as we anticipate an AR-platform rifle ought to.

Suppressor Prepared

Since pistol caliber carbines are immensely common little doubt due partially for his or her potential to be successfully suppressed, Windham Weaponry offered the 9mm Carbine with out a muzzle gadget – only a knurled thread protector on the hazard finish of the barrel. Unscrew the thread protector to reveal the muzzle gadget threads. Windham Weaponry’s web page for this explicit mannequin says these threads are ½” x 28 threads per inch – nevertheless I did word an organization e-newsletter that acknowledged all 9mm fashions are produced with ½” x 36 thread pitch. The ethical of this story: should you’re seeking to set up a suppressor in your Windham Weaponry 9mm, you should definitely double verify the thread pitch. 

I visited my buddy with the SIG Sauer MPX-C that I reviewed a pair years in the past so I may do a 9mm carbine comparability and reap the benefits of the SilencerCo Octane 9HD that he obtained for the SIG. Nonetheless, the muzzle thread pitches are totally totally different between the 2 weapons, so I sadly wasn’t in a position to play with the Windham Weaponry 9mm suppressed. And with the thread adapter for an Octane 9 being about $90, I’ll have to avoid wasting the suppressed report (pun meant) for a later date. However the potential is there, so a tax type is in my future, I predict. I imply, it solely is sensible, proper? Proper.

Not Dangerous Out Of the Field, However…

Windham Weaponry kits out the 9mm Carbine with customary AR accoutrements which can be completely purposeful, however I personally really feel a contact dated on this ergonomically enhanced and developed firearms worldview. The usual offered collapsible buttstock is a mildly-enhanced throwback to Colt’s Vietnam-induced CAR-15/XM177 design of the 1960s, and the A2 fashion pistol grip is unchanged for the reason that introduction of the M16A2 variant from the early 1980s. The black nylon sling is basically only a strap with zero fast adjustability when put in between the offered QD rail mount and the telescoping buttstock.

Some might argue that these designs are completely satisfactory and purposeful, and they’re completely proper. Nonetheless, after having my cheek pinched in some buttstock-receiver extension junctions a pair instances, and wrestling with making an attempt to retrofit a correct two-point sling on the buttstock, I simply bit the bullet and bought a black Magpul CTR buttstock and MOE pistol grip. These two easy additions added a contact of storage and a wholesome serving of elevated utility with the power to correctly mount a Blue Power Gear Vickers two-point sling on QD mounts fore and aft. This setup proved its price on a carbine course and through quite a few drills on the sandpit. Don’t get me improper: Windham Weaponry gives a serviceable setup out of the field – and props to them for offering an entire bundle – however for a number of additional bucks (MOE Grip – $20, CTR Inventory – $60, Blue Power Gear Sling $55) you get a pistol-caliber marvel carbine that desires for nothing within the ergonomics and utility division.

Heads up although: after I yanked the unique buttstock off the 9mm carbine to seek out that the inventory receiver is of the Business selection, not the Mil-Spec configuration. I checked with Windham Weaponry, they usually confirmed that almost all of their rifles exit the door with Business extensions, for the reason that .03” narrower diameter permits the usage of each Business and Mil-Spec shares. Simply be forewarned – it could be simpler to seek out extra colours and configurations within the Mil-Spec sizes (because the business as principally standardized the usage of Mil-Spec parts), however they’ll rattle and wiggle only a tiny bit when used on Business tubes. Absolutely purposeful, only a bit annoying, if that kind of factor bothers you. Simply an FYI.

The one different change I made was to swap out the inventory fashion charging deal with for a BCM Gunfighter Mod 4 piece with a left-side extension. Extra on the vital “why?” of that modification right here in a second – and it ain’t only for elevated deal with leverage.

You’ll additionally have to supply sights and/or an optic to run this carbine correctly. I had some kicking round, fortunately – however a set of decent BUIS will probably be most likely round $60-70 to start out – and optics can vary from Wal-Mart $39 cheapies to pink dots and ACOGs that may make you’re taking an unsteady knee whenever you pull out the pockets. The Windham Weaponry 9mm AR carbine’s picatinny rail will gladly give any of them a strong dwelling.

Yeah, However How Does It Shoot?

Ahh, right here’s the query I’m positive most of you’re dying to know the reply to. As quickly as this little beast was in my sweaty palms, I grabbed a pair containers of ammo and headed to the sandpit to get the 9mm Carbine dialed in and prepared for some real-world testing. A Vortex AMG UH-1 holographic sight was mounted on the rail together with some folding sights. I deliberate on dialing the rifle in for 100 yards – from earlier expertise with the SIG Sauer MPX I knew that was about as distant as a 9mm is completely satisfied to go.  The offered Magpul 17-round magazine was loaded up with some Winchester 124-grain FMJ ammo, and inside three pictures had the rifle on the right track at 25 yards. I went to a kneeling place, and making an attempt for an honest group, proceeded to plunk 4 rounds touching with no issues in any respect. A very good begin.

Associated: Survival Gear Review: SIG Sauer MPX-C

Just a few steps again to 50 yards confirmed that I used to be nonetheless on paper, and an adjustment to deliver the bullet influence about an inch excessive at 50 yards labored effectively. A five-shot group from the kneeling place at 50 yards measured about 1 ½” or so. I then stood, and proceeded to handily perforate a 1-liter soda bottle shot for shot on the 100-yard marker. The gun was a shooter for positive – higher than I anticipated. 

After I was testing handloads and another manufacturing facility ammunition by means of the Windham Weaponry 9mm carbine, I discovered that ensuing group dimension diversified wildly by bullet kind and weight, however all the masses produced usable accuracy – particularly when you think about {that a} stubby 9mm bullet ain’t precisely a ballistic marvel. I settled on a handload that performed good within the W-W carbine and my Glock 19; the load pushed a 124-grain Hornady FMJ bullet at about 1,250 fps – and grouped within the 4” vary at 100 yards. I believe the carbine may have performed a bit higher with a correct magnified optic, however the Vortex’s holographic reticle was quick and constructive to work with – and 100-yard 4” teams from a 9mm carbine was A-OK with me. Excessive-end defensive ammo did shoot markedly higher, with Remington Golden Saber 124-grain +P masses specifically offering wonderful accuracy.

The R16FTT-9MM proved to be boringly dependable. It wolfed up each nasty lead bulleted handload I made, each hole level protection load I supplied it, and each steel-cased crap Wolf load I dropped the hammer on. To today, with most likely shut to three,00zero rounds by means of the rifle, I’ve but to expertise a malfunction with the gun – although I ensure that to wash and lube the rifle typically as a result of blowback motion’s fast carbon buildup.

Working the 9mm Carbine within the Actual World

I lately took a carbine course by means of SRT Ideas right here in Maine (excellent firm for coaching, verify them out should you’re within the New England Space). I checked with Peter Joyce, the trainer, forward of time, and requested if I may run two weapons on the course so I may examine a pistol caliber carbine in opposition to my regular 5.56mm AR. He preferred the thought and welcomed me to run each weapons, so long as I used to be absolutely communicative about swapping weapons and following enhanced security procedures whereas strolling to and from the firing line with totally different rifles.

The carbine course was stellar, and an actual eye-opener with the perform, efficiency, and notion variations between the 2 calibers. On the bottom stage, the 2 weapons have been roughly the identical – my 5.56 AR even has a Windham Weaponry heavy barrel! – with collapsible Magpul shares, 16” barrels, and an identical sling setups. Optics have been totally different, as my 5.56 rifle sports activities a Leupold Mk AR 1.5x-4 on a Burris PEPR mount, whereas I elected to run the 9mm carbine with a non-magnified Vortex AMG UH-1 holographic sight in line with the close-in philosophy the pistol-caliber platform promotes.

Associated: Survival Gear Review: Windham Weaponry R18FSFSM-308

Each rifles carried out flawlessly, with both carbine proving to be ridiculously correct and completely able to offering straightforward hits underneath all circumstances and capturing positions. On the 75 yard mark and past, I did discover that the 9mm positively didn’t have the outright sensible accuracy and flat trajectory that the 5.56 afforded, however hits contained in the “kill” field have been easy in any respect ranges to 100 yards with the 9mm. A “operating man” drill with 90 9mm rounds in any respect distances from powder-burn vary to 100 yards, and launching bullets from a wide range of positions together with susceptible, offhand, weak-side transition, and from behind cowl with the rifle laying sideways and the buttstock mounted over the shoulder turned up an ideal rating with no rounds placing outdoors the scoring containers. I used a mixture of Winchester “White Field” 124-grain FMJ rounds and 124-grain FMJ handloads all through the course with no failures to perform. Recoil was positively negligible and the rifle was a breeze to fireside shortly and precisely. 

The fellows on the road both facet of me appreciated the 9mm carbine enormously. My 5.56 AR wears a Seekins Precision muzzle brake that’s vastly efficient at taming muzzle rise, however blasts concussively each time the rifle goes off. (I used to be advised by my teacher that the muzzle blast was flapping my neighbor’s shirt round!)  The 9mm carbine was launching 124-grain bullets at about 1,250 ft per second, making the rifle appear virtually suppressed as compared!. Reportedly the 9mm AR was far more comfy to face close to whereas I used to be capturing. Even with no muzzle gadget, there have been no points with muzzle rise or blast. This can be a main consideration for anybody probably operating this gun indoors – whether or not or not it’s a warrant-serving police officer, or a house owner defending his household.

The 9mm carbine’s fast dealing with traits have been a pleasure on the vary, and the security was constructive and crisp – a welcome attribute certainly, particularly when working close to different shooters with loads of distraction. Realizing by means of haptic suggestions – a pleasant constructive “click on” – that the security was absolutely engaged or absolutely disengaged after I operated it was a Godsend.

(Very  Minor) Bother in Paradise 

Points? Yeah, a pair – however these have been probably not the gun’s fault, simply struggles that manifested themselves through the variations in journal design. You see, as a result of feeding angle of Glock magazines imparted by Gaston Glock’s grip design, the Windham Weaponry’s magazines rake backwards barely within the journal effectively and require a distinct insertion angle when reloading from the shoulder. The place an ordinary 5.56mm journal inserts straight up into the journal effectively, the 9mm magazines require you to cant your wrist ahead and slant the highest of the journal barely ahead when inserting. I additionally had a little bit of luck inserting {a magazine} kind of like an AK, with the highest of the journal going through my head after which rocking it upwards and into the magwell. Nonetheless, this method didn’t work as effectively with tactical reloads whenever you needed to juggle two magazines with one hand. 

The opposite difficulty I discovered was that although magazines typically dropped free when the discharge was pushed, the smaller, lighter 17 and 15 spherical pistol mags very often had sufficient polymer-to-aluminum friction to hold up and require a yank or a shake whereas performing a reload from the shoulder. Not the tip of the world, however one other step to work by means of whenever you want the gun topped off in a rush. I did discover that this hang-up phenomenon occurred principally when the rifle had been able the place the journal had some lateral stress on it, normally from leaning in opposition to a barricade or cowl. 

Coaching and repetition will enable you by means of each of those points decisively, however I discovered that swapping backwards and forwards between the 9mm and 5.56 platforms had me confused when it got here time for quick reloads. Maintain that in thoughts should you like having plenty of totally different rifles.

BCM charging deal with (left) vs. inventory. Be aware the built-up half-circle space on the BCM.

The opposite drawback I’d discovered (really earlier than I took the course) centered across the 9mm carbine’s blowback working system. Each time the rifle went off, the gun cycled and scorching gasses from the expended cartridge made their method again by means of the charging deal with keyway, and blew immediately on my eyes. I by no means observed the issue whereas carrying eye safety, like I do 99% of the time – however the one time I didn’t use eye professional, the recent gasses expelling backwards rushed into my eyes like a rowdy warmth gun directed on my face. It was uncomfortable to say the least – and whereas dry eyes aren’t enjoyable, unburnt powder, case particles, or different carbon residue may journey with the gasses – probably disabling your eye. Lesson one: at all times use eye safety. Lesson two: ditch the inventory charging deal with and supply a alternative unit that has a built-up “wall” of fabric on the highest of the half – this mitigates the gasses properly. The BCM charging handle I dropped within the carbine (customary AR charging handles work simply high-quality!) enhanced the gun’s guide of arms with elevated leverage for working the bolt from the shoulder, and it deflected scorching gasses properly. 

Of all of the swapped elements I modified out on the Windham Weaponry 9mm carbine, I’d think about the charging deal with swap an important – an enormous security improve to your face and peepers. When the SHTF or that dwelling invader kicks the door open at 2am, assume you’ll be carrying security glasses? Even odds that you simply gained’t be. Maintain that in thoughts.

Brass Tacks

The pistol caliber carbine efficacy debate is a topic for a future article (one I’m trying ahead to certainly); we’re going to imagine that your plans dictate that the 9mm caliber is what you need, and also you’re seeking to reap the benefits of the Windham Weaponry R16FTT-9MM’s potential to make the most of Glock magazines. And why shouldn’t you? For Survival Cache’s target market – Preppers and Survivalists – the Windham Weaponry 9mm carbine gives you with a vastly efficient device to maximise your minimalist beliefs and necessities. Now not do you should maintain a number of journal sorts, ammunition calibers, and different logistical and maintenance accoutrements to produce your firearms wants; the Glock-mag-fed 9mm carbine fixes this difficulty for you. Run one caliber by means of one kind of magazines for each your lengthy weapons and sidearm. The low recoil, close-in effectiveness, and light-weight, fast dealing with would make this a stellar alternative as a coaching rifle of major arm for smaller-framed shooters, girls, and supervised, appropriately-aged youngsters as effectively.

I’ve written earlier than about Windham Weaponry’s outstanding commitment to quality and innovation – and this R16FTT-9MM is an ideal manifestation of each of those beliefs. This carbine is fantastically manufactured to a design that’s precisely what a 9mm AR ought to be. I do know I griped a tad concerning the equipment Windham Weaponry selected to incorporate with the bundle, however the very plain and easy reality is that this carbine is 100% serviceable and able to exit of the field when you throw a sighting system on. It’s additionally a fantastic beginning platform to construct a suppressed carbine, and even an SBR. The road worth of $900-950 for the Windham Weaponry R16FTT-9MM carbine could appear a bit steep when lesser corporations supply a bundle with ostensibly the identical options, however this can be a basic instance of getting what you pay for. The standard, design, reliability, match, and end are light-years forward of different corporations’ choices, and – maybe most significantly – Windham Weaponry’s transferable guarantee and customer support are excellent of their subject…which I can’t say about different corporations with, effectively, budget-minded merchandise. 

Should you assume this 9mm carbine is “Simply one other AR”, get previous your individual affirmation bias and check out one out. You’ll understand for your self that an AR in 9mm is an absolute platform enhancement when mixed with a sidearm that makes use of the identical feeding system. Pistol caliber carbines paired with a appropriate pistol are scorching proper now – shooters and preppers are recognizing the flexibility, effectiveness, and minimalist leanings of the idea. And there’s no higher combo (in my humble opinion) than a Glock 19 and a Windham Weaponry R16FTT-9MM carbine. Seize one in every of every (or extra, that’s cool too), top off on low cost, dependable magazines and a few circumstances of ammo, and proudly possess the perfect pairing of capturing instruments in the marketplace – they’re prepared when you find yourself, it doesn’t matter what hits the fan. 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here